Maple Leafs were warned not to sign Sergei Bobrovsky
What we've found over the last 12 years at Clear Sight is that at age 38, that's the major decline risk signal. And for older goalies, minus-15 is often the beginning of structural decline. Once older goalies fall below that minus-15 line, recovery becomes much less likely at this age. A poor season is more often a structural decline, and it's a strong signal that this isn't just a short-term performance dip. I know the Leafs received this report that I put together before free agency. And I don't know if Chayka got it. I don't know, I just know that this found a way into management.
The Leafs gave Bobrovsky three years at $7 million per season. He's off to a brutal start, as one of the worst goalies in the league, posting a 3-9-2 record, with a .874 save percentage, and 3.65 goals against average. Valiquette feels this was avoidable. "You have to take a step back and look at it as in: 'How many goals can we afford to allow during an NHL season to make the playoffs?'" Valiquette said. "I've done a lot of research on this over the last six months. Coming into this season, before the 84-game schedule, the number was always 250."
Sergei Bobrovsky can’t be traded, sent to the minors or waived without his consent. As a 35+ contract, his full cap hit also counts against the salary cap in a buyout.
— Scott Wheeler (@scottcwheeler) November 18, 2026
"When you allow fewer than 250 goals in a season, you have an 83 percent chance to make the playoffs. So that's where I would start, because you have to find out where the blame falls. Is it on the team defense or is it on the goaltending?"
Should the Leafs have listened? It appears so at this point of the season.