NHL Exec Says Matthews & Nylander Trades Should Be In Maple Leafs Future
When I asked one Western Conference team executive what he would do if he were in the Leafs’ position and their season didn’t turn around, he said they would probably have to go to Matthews and William Nylander and ask how they’d feel about being moved.
The exec told LeBrun, “Hope to get some first (round picks) back by moving big guys and start over, but not sure Toronto fans will allow that. I really am not sure what they do."
'Big, sweeping moves' are the only way out for the Leafs: NHL executive
He added that “It’s a tough one if they keep going this way. The only way to change, I feel, is big, sweeping and major moves.”
Kevin Hayes agreed, telling the rest of the Spittin' Chiclets crew that the captain is certainly on his way out.
We got our first Hayesy Hot Take and he's calling that Auston Matthews will be on his way out of Toronto 👀 https://t.co/WX9hBtNQh5
— Spittin' Chiclets (@spittinchiclets) November 18, 2026
"Matthews is gone. He's gone."
Matthews has one more year to run after this one on his four-year, $13.25M AAV contract. But the Leafs simply cannot take the chance of going into next season with the captain on an expiring deal. They cannot repeat the Mitch Marner Experience.
Nylander, unfortunately, still has five more years to run at an $11.5M cap hit. That one will be a much more difficult thing to deal with.
If a dramatic, miraculous turnaround isn't in the offing soon, a Matthews (and Nylander, if anyone is interested) trade is a very realistic possibility.