Report: Penguins Would Consider Sidney Crosby Trade

The Pittsburgh Penguins aren’t going to stand in Sidney Crosby’s way, whatever he decides.

The Athletic’s Josh Yohe laid out where things stand with the Penguins captain this week, and the bottom line is that it’s entirely his call.

“The truth is, everything is in his hands,” Yohe wrote.

“If Crosby wants to keep playing with the Penguins after this season, they will naturally accommodate his wishes. If he wants to retire after this season, he will retire. If he wants to be traded, Dubas will trade him.”

In other words, GM Kyle Dubas won’t be the one standing in the way.

Crosby Holds All The Cards

Crosby has a full no-movement clause on his two-year, $17.4 million extension, which carries an $8.7 million cap hit and expires July 1, so he’d have to sign off on any trade.

He’s also long said he only wants to play for the Penguins.

But according to Yohe, even Crosby doesn’t seem to have a clear answer right now.

Most people Yohe has talked to inside the organization expect Crosby back next season, though “no one truly knows because Crosby doesn’t seem to know what he wants to do.”

The Penguins plan to handle Evgeni Malkin’s future the same way.

“Given who he is, the Penguins are happy to let him play out this season in Pittsburgh,” Yohe wrote of Malkin.

Tough Season In Pittsburgh

The bigger issue is where the Penguins are as a team.

Pittsburgh made it back to the playoffs in 2025-26, but this season has been a different story, with the Penguins at 7-11-2 through their first 20 games.

Crosby is having a slower year than usual, with six goals and 13 points so far.

He’s still adding to his legacy, though.

The 39-year-old moved into sole possession of sixth place on the NHL’s all-time points list earlier this month, and he broke Ray Bourque’s record for the most assists with a single franchise on Halloween night.

He now has 660 goals and 1,114 assists for 1,774 points in 1,440 games, all of them with Pittsburgh. He's just 24 points back of Ron Francis for 5th all time.

Social Media Feature Preview