Maple Leafs: Surprising Mitch Marner Replacement Linked To Toronto

Friday, May 30, 2025 ,
Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube looks on during 2025 game.

The Toronto Maple Leafs are bracing for a major shakeup this offseason—and Mitch Marner’s expected departure might be just the beginning. 

The longtime Leaf is likely headed to free agency after another disappointing playoff run, leaving a massive hole in Toronto’s top six. One name gaining traction as a potential replacement? New York Rangers forward Chris Kreider.

According to insider David Pagnotta of The Fourth Period, the Leafs may explore a trade for the 34-year-old Kreider if the Rangers shop him again this summer. Kreider carries a $6.5 million cap hit for two more seasons and is coming off a down year, but his rugged style and playoff scoring pedigree—76 points in 123 postseason games—could help Toronto address its long-running playoff struggles.

Kreider’s Fit in Toronto: Short-Term Fix or Risky Bet?

While Kreider isn’t a one-for-one replacement for Marner’s playmaking magic, his physicality, experience, and finishing touch could complement a Leafs lineup craving grit and postseason performance. Toronto has the cap space to absorb his contract, and if New York retains salary, the deal could be even more appealing. But there’s debate over whether Kreider is the right target for a team that should be getting younger, not older.

Some analysts argue that alternatives like Nikolaj Ehlers or Brock Boeser would offer better long-term upside. Ehlers, for instance, could cost around $8 million AAV but brings elite offensive skill and more runway than Kreider, who’s entering the twilight of his career. Still, if the Leafs prioritize winning now and want proven playoff production, Kreider’s track record offers plenty of value.

Trade Talks May Depend on Rangers’ Direction

Kreider has made it clear he wants to stay in New York, but the Rangers’ desire to free up cap space could make him expendable. GM Chris Drury reportedly fielded offers last season and may do so again. For Toronto, this creates a low-risk opportunity to bring in a veteran leader if the price is right, and potentially soften the blow of losing Marner.

Photo Credit: Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images

Go To: NFL Rumors | NBA Rumors | MLB Rumors